Market News 10 min read

Is AB Foods a Good Long-Term Investment? ABF Growth, Profitability and Risks

AB Foods profit fell 14% to £1,508m and Sugar is now guided to lose £70m-£170m in 2027, with the Primark demerger confirmed for December 2027.

A sturdy wooden table neatly split down the middle, with one side holding a well-kept cash box and the other a sagging sack spilling white sugar onto the floor

Associated British Foods reported adjusted operating profit of £1,508m for the 52 weeks to 12 September 2026 — down 14% at constant currency, or 13% at actual rates — on revenue of £19.58bn, down 1% at constant currency. Adjusted earnings per share fell 11% to 156.0p. The material part was not the year just gone but the year ahead: the board said group adjusted operating profit and adjusted EPS in 2027 will both come in below 2026, principally because the Sugar division is now guided to an adjusted operating loss of £70m to £170m, against a £47m loss just reported. The shares eased by roughly 2% to 3% on the 3 November release, from a previous close near 1,943p to around 1,880p.

For anyone asking whether AB Foods is a good long-term investment, the numbers now support a narrower proposition than they did two years ago, and the demerger makes it literal. What they support is Primark: adjusted operating profit of about £1.0bn on a 10.2% margin, with sales up 2% to roughly £9.8bn and the group guiding to a margin of approximately 10% in 2027 before demerger dis-synergy costs. What they argue against is holding the group as a conglomerate — two consecutive years of falling profit with a third guided, a maintained dividend funded from a shrinking earnings base, and a Sugar business whose guided loss range for a single year spans £100m of uncertainty. For the long-term case to work, three things have to go right: European sugar prices and energy costs have to stop deteriorating, Primark's investment in price, marketing and digital has to convert into like-for-like growth rather than just margin give-back, and the December 2027 demerger has to separate the two without destroying more value in dis-synergies than it releases in rating. None of those is resolved by this release. All three now have dates.

What actually happened

The group result was weak across the board. Adjusted operating profit of £1,508m against revenue of £19.58bn puts the group margin at about 7.7%, and profit fell in Primark, Sugar and Grocery. The constant-currency versus actual-currency distinction matters here and is routinely muddled in coverage: the fall is 14% at constant currency and 13% at actual rates, so quotations of "13%" and "14%" are both correct on their own basis. Adjusted EPS fell 11% to 156.0p, declining more slowly than operating profit.

Primark. Adjusted operating profit fell 12% to approximately £1.0bn, with the adjusted operating margin at 10.2%. Total sales rose about 2% to roughly £9.8bn, but that growth came from space rather than from existing stores — like-for-like sales slipped — and the margin decline was attributed to deliberate investment in price, marketing and digital capability. Management guided the 2027 margin to approximately 10%, and was explicit that this figure excludes the dis-synergy costs that will arrive as Primark is prepared for separation.

Sugar. This is the division that changed the story. The segment reported an adjusted operating loss of £47m for 2026, having been close to break-even in 2025, with sales down 9% on lower average European selling prices and an increase in onerous contract provisions. The guidance for 2027 is an adjusted operating loss of £70m to £170m, attributed to higher energy costs, continued low European sugar prices and difficult production conditions. The width of that range — £100m on a group that just earned £1,508m — is itself the disclosure: management cited uncertainty over gas costs, African production levels and currency. Against that, the company noted that the recent rise in world sugar prices should benefit later years.

The structure. The December 2027 demerger of Primark from the food businesses was confirmed on schedule, and the dividend was maintained.

Why the market reacted the way it did

A fall of only a few per cent on a 14% profit decline and a guided third consecutive down year is the most informative thing in this release. It tells you the market had already written the conglomerate discount in.

Two mechanisms explain the muted reaction. First, almost none of this was new information. ABF had already cut its 2026 Sugar guidance to a £25m-£60m loss in July, then said in September that the outcome would land towards the top of that range on higher onerous contract provisions. The £47m printed inside the pre-signalled band. The 2027 widening to £70m-£170m had also been flagged ahead of the full results. A company that pre-announces its disappointments does not get re-rated by confirming them.

Second, the demerger changes what the share price is discounting. From December 2027 there is no "AB Foods" to own — there is Primark, and there is a rump of Grocery, Sugar, Ingredients and Agriculture. Investors are therefore pricing two assets, not one, and a bad year in Sugar damages one of them while leaving the other's separation timetable intact. That is a very different reaction function from the one a single-business profit warning would trigger, and it explains why a maintained dividend and a confirmed demerger date were enough to contain the fall to the low single digits.

The Openbook read

The honest way to score ABF today is to refuse to score the group, because the group is a scheduled fiction with a termination date. We read it as two assets.

Growth is poor on any group-level measure and should not be rescued by averaging. Revenue fell 1% at constant currency; adjusted operating profit fell 14%; adjusted EPS fell 11%; and 2027 is guided lower again on both profit and EPS. Primark's 2% sales growth is the only positive growth figure of consequence, and because like-for-like sales slipped, it is space-driven — the lowest-quality form of retail growth, since it consumes capital to produce it. A two-year sequence of declining profit with a third guided is a genuine growth-factor failure, not a cyclical blip.

Profitability splits sharply. Primark at a 10.2% adjusted operating margin remains a good value-retail business by any international comparison, and guiding to approximately 10% next year — while investing — is a defensible outcome rather than a deterioration. Sugar is the opposite: a loss-making division guided to lose between £70m and £170m, which at the top of the range would consume more than 11% of the group's current adjusted operating profit. The group margin of roughly 7.7% is an average of those two realities and tells you almost nothing useful about either.

Solvency is the factor that looks adequate but is quietly tightening. The dividend was maintained from a lower earnings base, and the adjusted EPS of 156.0p is falling again next year — so cover is narrowing by arithmetic. Meanwhile Sugar is a cash-consuming division with onerous contract provisions already recognised, and the demerger will bring one-off separation costs and dis-synergies that management has flagged but not quantified against the Primark margin. None of that constitutes balance-sheet stress at a group of this scale, but the direction over the next five quarters is towards less headroom, not more.

Momentum is weak and getting weaker on the estimate-revision component. The company has now guided analysts to cut 2027 profit and EPS forecasts, and the price action has been a slow grind rather than a shock — which is the typical signature of a de-rating story rather than an event-driven one.

Reward/Risk is where the demerger genuinely alters the picture, and in both directions. The upside case is mechanical: a listed Primark earning around £1.0bn at a 10% margin, valued as a pure value-retailer rather than inside a food conglomerate, plausibly commands a different rating from the one embedded today. The downside case is that the separation lands Primark with standalone costs it has never carried and leaves the food rump holding a Sugar division in the middle of a three-year loss run with a £100m-wide guidance band. The risk is not that the group fails; it is that the sum of the parts turns out to be smaller than the parts argument assumes, because the dis-synergies are real and the Sugar loss is not yet bounded. Readers can set the current factor profile against the rest of UK retail and food on our screener, or start from the AB Foods factor page.

The read-across

The Primark read-across is the one with the broadest relevance. A value retailer growing total sales 2% while like-for-like slips, and giving back margin to invest in price and marketing, is evidence that the UK and European value-apparel channel is competing on price rather than expanding. That is a datapoint for Next, Marks & Spencer, Inditex and H&M — and particularly for anyone assuming Primark's margin is a stable floor. It has just moved from 10.2% towards 10%, with separation costs still to come.

The Sugar read-across runs to European sugar processors and to the food manufacturers that buy from them. ABF's guided loss is driven by low European selling prices and high energy costs, which is the same squeeze facing every beet processor on the continent. For food manufacturers, low European sugar prices are an input-cost benefit, so this is a transfer rather than a sector-wide loss — but it means ABF's own Grocery and Ingredients divisions are not natural hedges against the Sugar problem in the way a vertically integrated story implies.

The broader index point is about conglomerate structures. ABF is the FTSE 100's clearest current example of a group whose own board has concluded that the parts are worth more separated. Holders of other UK multi-division groups should note how little the market paid for the news that the combined entity's profit fell 14% — because the market was already valuing the separation, not the combination.

What to watch next

  • The Christmas trading update, due January 2027. Primark's like-for-like performance over the peak season is the test of whether the price and marketing investment is working. Total sales growth will not answer it; like-for-like will.
  • Where Sugar lands inside the £70m-£170m range. The interim results in spring 2027 are the first hard read. European selling prices, gas costs and African production volumes are the three variables management named, and the half-year commentary should narrow the band.
  • Quantification of demerger dis-synergies. Management guided Primark's 2027 margin to approximately 10% explicitly excluding these costs. The number, when it comes, is the difference between a clean separation and an expensive one.
  • Dividend cover into a guided-down year. With adjusted EPS of 156.0p falling again in 2027 and the payout maintained, the board's stance at the interim is a direct signal on how it is funding the demerger.
  • The December 2027 demerger timetable itself. Any slippage would be the most significant single piece of news available on this share.

The long-term question about AB Foods is no longer really about AB Foods. It is about whether you want to own a value retailer with a 10% margin and a stalling like-for-like, a food and sugar business with a £100m-wide loss range, or both for fourteen more months while someone else pays the separation bill.

Was this useful?
Sign in to vote
4 of 4
Compare ABF, NXT, MKS, TSCO